Dairy-Free • Egg • Contains Gluten • No Commercial Yeast
2 large loaves
Advanced
1 hour
18–24 hours
HaMotzi
This sourdough challah recipe recreates the bread your great-great-grandmother made — before commercial yeast existed.
For thousands of years, every loaf of bread that rose on a Jewish table did so without a single packet of instant yeast. There was only flour, water, wild fermentation, and time. The sourdough starter — a living culture of wild yeast and beneficial bacteria, sustained by nothing more than regular feedings of flour and water — was the original leavening. It was the engine behind every challah pulled from a wood-fired oven in Vilna, in Kraków, in the shtetls of the Pale of Settlement. This is not a modern twist on an old recipe. This is the old recipe. Everything else came later.
What you will discover here is a challah unlike anything commercial yeast can produce. The crumb is open and tender, laced with a complex tang that plays against the sweetness of honey in a way that is deeply, unmistakably alive. The crust bakes to a deep caramel brown with a fragrance that fills the entire house — warm, wheaty, faintly acidic, ancient. It demands patience. It rewards attention. And when you pull these braided loaves from the oven on a Friday afternoon, you are not just baking bread. You are reaching back through centuries of Jewish baking tradition and carrying it forward with your own hands.
Advanced bakers, this is your summit. If you have mastered our Classic Challah, you are ready. If you have not, start there first — then come back here when you are ready to climb.