Dairy
Contains Butter • Egg • Milk • Contains Gluten
Yield
2 loaves (16–20 slices)
Difficulty
Intermediate–Advanced
Active Time
45 minutes
Total Time
5–6 hours (or overnight)
Bracha
HaMotzi or Mezonot*
*See Brachot section below — depends on quantity eaten and meal context.
Cinnamon babka is the other babka — and for many, it is the better babka. While chocolate babka commands the spotlight in bakery windows from Brooklyn to Bnei Brak, the cinnamon version is the quieter triumph: a bread that trades drama for depth, where ribbons of cinnamon-brown sugar wind through a butter-rich dough so tender it tears like silk. Every slice reveals a new landscape of swirled layers, each one glistening with caramelized sugar and warm spice.
The great cinnamon-versus-chocolate debate has raged in Jewish bakeries for decades. Jerry Seinfeld famously declared cinnamon a lesser babka, but legions of bakers and grandmothers disagree. Chocolate impresses on first bite; cinnamon rewards on the fifth, the tenth, the last crumb scraped from the pan. Its sweetness is more subtle, more layered — brown sugar that darkens and deepens in the oven, cinnamon that blooms with heat, butter that caramelizes at the edges. This is a babka that tastes like the memory of every great kitchen you have ever walked into.
What elevates this recipe from good to extraordinary are three finishing touches: a crunchy streusel topping that shatters against the soft crumb, a simple syrup soak brushed on while the loaves are still hot (sealing in moisture and adding a delicate sheen), and an overnight cold rise that develops flavor no short-cut method can replicate. The result is a babka that stays moist for days — not that it will last that long.
If you have baked our Chocolate Babka, you already know this dough. The two share the same rich, brioche-like foundation — it is the filling that transforms each into something entirely different. Master one, and the other is yours.